It’s no secret I’m a sucker for cover variants. They’re one of the few variants I collect. And this release will ultimately lead to far more money leaving my bank account than I would ever like.
There are five cover variants for this soundtrack. Dark Nights: Death Metal is a joint comic and music series between DC comics and a handful or bands and artists spanning several genres. In the lead up to the complete soundtrack being released, three comics were released with exclusive flexi discs. These flexi discs featured songs selected off the soundtrack, and cost $15 before shipping. I believe all the comics were the same, at least content wise. Ironically, all three of them were cover variants. Which is an even bigger thing in the comic collecting scene than it is with vinyl.
Admittedly I’m not a fan of comics at all. I’ve never seen the appeal of them. Reading in general really. Which I’m aware is the ultimate irony of someone writing a blog who has a writing degree. So I have no idea what the comic series revolves around. But the music is why most of us are here, and hopefully reading…
The soundtrack features the likes of Manchester Orchestra, Rise Against, Mastodon and of course Tyler Bates: who can’t seem to not be involved with a comic or graphic novel related soundtrack or score. Needless to say I bought this for the Manchester Orchestra song, which happens to be a b-side from the Cope era. So the band has been sitting on this for years. The song was re-worked under the guidance and support of Tyler Bates (executive producer of the soundtrack), who approached the band about being involved with this soundtrack, and it was thusly included on it. The song is titled “Never Ending,” and I’m not sure if that was the title the song originally had or not.
Loma Vista released the soundtrack, which explains the exorbitant amount of variants all around for this record. They shared the wealth with many of the retailers who charge the highest prices for their exclusive variants. Most notably FYE and Newbury Comics. At least I only had to indulge one of them.
Before delving into the full pressing info, here are some of the most pertinent details about this release. All copies are pressed as a double LP, housed in a gatefold jacket, which includes an obi-strip. All the variants except for the black one contain at least one of 11 different trading cards are included, along with a foldout poster. I say at least one trading card because apparently, for whatever reason, some copies come with multiple, while others come with only one. On that note, not all copies come with inserts, while others do. Basically what I’m trying to say is that this release is a convoluted mess of details.
I will start out with the most widely used cover variant, which has multiple record variants inside itself. Pressing info has not been released for all of these variants however, but they do have the most filled out info for any of them. First up is the standard black, which is available everywhere selling this soundtrack aside from retailers that may have an exclusive variant featuring this cover, and limited to an unknown amount. Barnes & Noble (B&N) has an exclusive variant, which is on blue (opaque) vinyl limited to an unknown amount. Brooklyn Vegan and Revolver Magazine each have an apparent variant, but for whatever reason both places are selling both colors. These colors, which are each limited to 500 copies a piece, are red and yellow. The aforementioned FYE exclusive has this cover art, and is pressed on “orchid” color vinyl, which is purple in color. Anyone who knows anything about plants, flowers, orchids in general knows or has a passing fancy of random facts knows that orchids come in a wide array of colors. So choosing a shade of purple is awfully presumptuous. To further complicate matters, there is an apparent European pressing/variant, which is also done on purple. I have not seen actual photos of either of these variants, but the mock up on the FYE web site depicts their exclusive being more of an opaque lilac or lavender color. How many copies were pressed on the FYE nor the Euro pressing/variant have been released.
Because there are so many variants, the standard artwork needs multiple paragraphs. So here we go again. Not to be outdone, Walmart has an exclusive color, pressed on orange (opaque) vinyl, and again without pressing info released. And this paragraph was needed even before going into the pricing of these exclusive variants.
Unsurprisingly the Walmart exclusive if the most affordable of the bunch, coming in at $28. Brooklyn Vegan and Revolver charged $33. B&N charged $30, along with Loma Vista for the black variant. But with that said, pricing on the black variant with the standard artwork varies based on where you buy it. But unless there is a sale or a drastic markdown before any coupon codes, the price won’t be below $25. All these prices are before shipping and tax, should they apply.
Now here come the cover variants. There is an indie record store exclusive cover, which has the record pressed on “electric smoke” vinyl. Pressing info has not been released for this variant, and price will vary based on the store you purchase from. But it will likely be between $27-32. The indie record store cover variant features the Dark Nights Death Metal version of Superman. With the color of the record being a clear base with black smoke. This variant is featured in the gallery below, with very detailed pictures of it.
The next cover variant up is the Newbury Comics one, which features Dark Nights Death Metal version of Batman. It’s pressed on black marble vinyl limited to 2,000 copies. This is the most expensive variant of the bunch, costing $40. The black marble variant is actually a perfect description of the record. It’s impossible to know of the base color is black or grey. Either way, it lives up the marble, which at least has white, black and grey mixed in. This variant also comes with an exclusive obi-strip, which is black in color on the front half, instead of yellow.
Comic book stores were of course not left out of the mix, as they have their own cover variant of the soundtrack. It features the Dark Nights Death Metal version of Wonder Woman, and is pressed on “smoke” vinyl according to item descriptions, despite the fact the hype sticker stating red smoke. Either way, that description could not be further from the truth. This “smoke” variant turned out to be transparent red w/ black marble. Admittedly I’m at a loss for words here with the pricing for this variant, as I’m unfamiliar with comic book stores. This variant is tough to find for sale online from any of the numerous indie comic book stores around the country. The few I have come across are charging upwards of $40 for it, with the most expensive one I found was a ridiculous $60 (before shipping of course). Very few have popped up for sale on the secondary market, and those that have are listed for sale at even higher numbers. Which isn’t surprising if you consider these flippers likely had to pay the aforementioned ludicrous retail prices.
The final variant was a label exclusive. It features the standard artwork, but with a different finish. This different finish is a mirrorboard. It’s limited to 2,000 copies on blue & purple smoke vinyl. Which is actually one of the most accurate descriptions of any of the variants for this record. The first disc is a transparent base with black smoke, and the second disc is a transparent purple base with black smoke. This variant cost $30, and quickly sold out.