Alkaline Trio have been no strangers to epic live shows. Not only that, but also releasing them to the public, even on vinyl. Their latest venture is performing their entire discography (up to My Shame Is True, which was their latest album at the time) recorded over four nights (two albums per show) at The Metro in Chicago. That venue should be familiar to Alkaline Trio fans as the band released a live 7” from one of their somewhat annual Halloween shows at The Metro.
The shows were held way back in 2014, but the band decided to release a vinyl (only physical audio release of the shows) box set in 2017/2018 (I’ll explain later) on their own label, Heart & Skull. This box set is titled Past Live, with all eight albums coming in their own single pocket jacket, which are then placed inside a slip case box. Each of the albums has re-imagined album art, with the color of the record itself matching the cover art. You can see by the photos below, but to sum up a yellow jacket gets a yellow record, red jacket gets a red record, and so on.
All the records are pressed on 180 gram vinyl, and come with both an insert and download card/code. The insert is single sided, which is a bit of a bummer. But it’s my only complaint about this box set, and it’s a minor one at that. The inserts are also all color coded as well. The download card/code nets you high quality 320 kbps MP3s. A nice touch that is thrown in with the box set is an autographed insert, which is screen printed on card stock. This insert comes sealed inside the box. It’s hand numbered out of 500, which implies there were 500 box sets made/pressed.
The only way to get the box set was to buy one of two bundle options; one that included a copy of the show on a four disc blu-ray set and an exclusive t-shirt of the box set artwork, and the other included the aforementioned blu-ray and t-shirt along with a tote bag made out of the stage banner used for the show. The non-tote bag bundle cost $275 with free shipping, while the tote bag bundle cost $315 with free shipping. Each of the live albums were also made available for purchase as standalone options, with each costing $25.
Here is the color beak down: Goddamnnit is pink, Maybe I’ll Catch Fire is purple, From Here To Infirmary is blue (baby/sky blue), Good Mourning is mint green, Crimson is neon green, Agony & Irony is yellow, This Addiction is orange and My Shame Is True is red. While most of the records are completely opaque, From Here To Infirmary, Crimson and This Addiction each have some marbling/smoke/haze mixed in. You can really only see it if you hold the record(s) up to the light, and the mixture is either a lighter/brighter or darker shade of the main color. So baby/sky blue, neon green or orange in these cases. And this is not to say these records for Crimson and This Addiction are translucent, they’re just not 100% opaque like the other records in this box set.
There was a lot of confusion and misleading statements made with pre-orders and the general release of this box set. First off, it was a limited time pre-order, which was only available for a certain period of time with an order cutoff date set. Pre-orders went live January 11, 2018 and the cutoff date was February 9, 2018. Then on Facebook the band announced pre-orders would be kept open for a few more days, till February 14. Not the biggest deal because it meant more people would be able to buy this. But it was the first in a long string of lies and misleading information.
The pre-order page for the box set said that only the amount of copies ordered would be made/pressed, and most of us know that is not exactly how ordering vinyl records goes. You can’t really order say 323 copies of anything as most plants just won’t let you order an odd amount like that. And that is before even taking into account the typical 10% overrun most plants do for quality control’s sake. Basically that wording in the pre-order was a sales tactic; a fancy buzz word used to make this release seem rare/ more limited. . Needless to say pressing info for the box set nor the standalone copies of the albums has never been officialy released, and it likely never will be. Though the autographed inserts included inside the box set are hand numbered out of 500 copies; no official announcement was made regarding pressing info for either the box set or any of the live albums themselves.
It was also implied during the pre-order phase for the standalone albums that they would be exclusive to the pre-order and not available anywhere else. That turned out to not be true as many indie record stores around the world; not just the U.S., had all eight albums available for purchase. Only kick was that pracitcally every store charged $35 for these single LPs.
The squirrelliness didn’t stop there either, as Kings Road Merch (KRM), who handled the pre-order, pulled the free shipping after about one week, and never re-applied it. They never made any mention of the free shipping being a limited time deal, and never answered emails asking about it. When shipping was being applied to orders it was around $20 depending on where you live. That shipping charge is a total rip off as the person I bought it from off ebay was able to ship it for $5 and change.
Pre-orders went live in mid January 2018, with a release date of April. No exact date in April was given. This release date was missed by a wide margin, as there was a delay with everything (shocking, huh). The new release date was pushed back to an unspecified date, and that release date was missed as well, as KRM sent out another e-mail at the end of May saying it was delayed again. With the typical BS excuse of we didn’t expect there to be delays with pressing records, and that “everything was on their way to KRM’s warehouse for assembly.”
June came and went without an update, but KRM sent out digital downloads to everyone who ordered an audio version of any of the album(s) they ordered. Which hardly makes up for the delay as all of the albums were made available for free streaming on Spotify. People didn’t start receiving their orders until July, and KRM didn’t even bother to send them a shipping notice let alone a tracking number; for a close to $300 item.
If you were keeping track of KRM’s “customer service,” they only sent out two generic e-mails about the months long delay, and never told customers their orders shipped. They just started showing up at people’s doorsteps. Sadly this is not surprising as KRM is one of the least reliable distros out there. And their shoddy communication track record resulted in a fair share of people cancelling their order.
Lots of factors contributed to me not pre-ordering this; the price, KRM being involved, the odd phrasing of the pre-order. Least of which was my general stance on not pre-ordering anything anymore. And everything that happened with this box set is exactly why I don’t pre-order anything. I was able to buy the box set on ebay for less than MSRP. It was solely due to a 15% off code. I didn’t get the blu-ray, the shirt or tote bag; but I didn’t want nor need any of those three things. And I know from past experiences it would be tough to sell those items and recoup what they cost. And yes, I did support a flipper (but not a well know one nor one who wanted a ridiculous price like $500 for the box set). But like I said, with the 15% off coupon I was able to get this for a lot less than $275. And I didn’t have to pre-order it and deal with that headache. So I win.